Comments on: Compare and Contrast http://bluecord.org/biblioblog/2006/04/compare-and-contrast/ A biblioblog Thu, 04 Dec 2008 22:28:00 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.5 By: Awilum.com » Great Intro to a “Hybrid Theory” of Source Criticism http://bluecord.org/biblioblog/2006/04/compare-and-contrast/#comment-28 Awilum.com » Great Intro to a “Hybrid Theory” of Source Criticism Wed, 03 May 2006 00:20:23 +0000 http://bluecord.org/biblioblog/2006/04/compare-and-contrast/#comment-28 [...] Kevin Wilson keeps churning out the great posts by bucking the system(s) and creating a “hybrid theory” of source criticism. It’s not the Documentary Hypothesis and it’s not quite the Supplementary Hypothesis–but it is the best of both in a nice, beautiful package. Check out this link, it’s only a quick snapshot of his views, but it’s a good summary. Kevin has a bright future ahead of him and I can’t wait to see a forthcoming monograph on this topic (hey, I asked him to write a post about it and he obliged, let’s see if I can get a full book length treatment out of him!). [...] […] Kevin Wilson keeps churning out the great posts by bucking the system(s) and creating a “hybrid theory” of source criticism. It’s not the Documentary Hypothesis and it’s not quite the Supplementary Hypothesis–but it is the best of both in a nice, beautiful package. Check out this link, it’s only a quick snapshot of his views, but it’s a good summary. Kevin has a bright future ahead of him and I can’t wait to see a forthcoming monograph on this topic (hey, I asked him to write a post about it and he obliged, let’s see if I can get a full book length treatment out of him!). […]

]]> By: Dr. Cathey’s Blog » Blog Archive » Kevin, Kevin, and Sacred Cows http://bluecord.org/biblioblog/2006/04/compare-and-contrast/#comment-23 Dr. Cathey’s Blog » Blog Archive » Kevin, Kevin, and Sacred Cows Tue, 02 May 2006 13:21:24 +0000 http://bluecord.org/biblioblog/2006/04/compare-and-contrast/#comment-23 [...] Now Kevin Wilson has taken umbrage at Mr. Edgecomb's assertations concerning the sacred cow. In this post he gets the ball to rolling by noting some criticisms in Edgecomb's posts. He further refines his argument with Edgecomb in this post. A delightful cornucopia of Gilgamesh and other ancient Near Eastern texts are tossed about in both posts. I am quite pleased to see Gilgamesh as well as other ancient Near Eastern rulers revived to do battle with the sacred cow of source criticism. This all proves of course that the Bull of Heaven is not yet slain by the mighty Gilgamesh (pun intended). [...] […] Now Kevin Wilson has taken umbrage at Mr. Edgecomb's assertations concerning the sacred cow. In this post he gets the ball to rolling by noting some criticisms in Edgecomb's posts. He further refines his argument with Edgecomb in this post. A delightful cornucopia of Gilgamesh and other ancient Near Eastern texts are tossed about in both posts. I am quite pleased to see Gilgamesh as well as other ancient Near Eastern rulers revived to do battle with the sacred cow of source criticism. This all proves of course that the Bull of Heaven is not yet slain by the mighty Gilgamesh (pun intended). […]

]]> By: biblicalia » Blog Archive » Compare and Contrast http://bluecord.org/biblioblog/2006/04/compare-and-contrast/#comment-20 biblicalia » Blog Archive » Compare and Contrast Sun, 30 Apr 2006 23:22:44 +0000 http://bluecord.org/biblioblog/2006/04/compare-and-contrast/#comment-20 [...] Kevin Wilson at Blue Cord has raised some interesting and quite valid points regarding my Discovery and Scholarship post, prompted by and added to by Charles Halton at Awilum. (Sorry about the primitive linking here, this “pingback” stuff is too new voodoo for me.) [...] […] Kevin Wilson at Blue Cord has raised some interesting and quite valid points regarding my Discovery and Scholarship post, prompted by and added to by Charles Halton at Awilum. (Sorry about the primitive linking here, this “pingback” stuff is too new voodoo for me.) […]

]]> By: Kevin P. Edgecomb http://bluecord.org/biblioblog/2006/04/compare-and-contrast/#comment-19 Kevin P. Edgecomb Sun, 30 Apr 2006 19:25:24 +0000 http://bluecord.org/biblioblog/2006/04/compare-and-contrast/#comment-19 I think the excesses of my rhetoric precede me, even if the B at the end of my name does not. I enjoy the interaction, of course, from a co-Kevin in Lithuania at that! I'll post some clarfication in a few minutes. I think the excesses of my rhetoric precede me, even if the B at the end of my name does not.

I enjoy the interaction, of course, from a co-Kevin in Lithuania at that! I’ll post some clarfication in a few minutes.

]]> By: Awilum.com » Kevin (Wilson) Responds http://bluecord.org/biblioblog/2006/04/compare-and-contrast/#comment-18 Awilum.com » Kevin (Wilson) Responds Sat, 29 Apr 2006 15:40:44 +0000 http://bluecord.org/biblioblog/2006/04/compare-and-contrast/#comment-18 [...] I really like digital communication.  It lets scholars communicate with each other with ease.  In my last post (written from Cincinnati, Ohio) I referred to a post (written in Berkeley, California) on the subject of higher criticism.  I was wanting to get Kevin Wilson’s take on it since he has done extensive work in this area and he graciously obliged (writing from Lithuania).  Thanks for the insightful response! [...] […] I really like digital communication.  It lets scholars communicate with each other with ease.  In my last post (written from Cincinnati, Ohio) I referred to a post (written in Berkeley, California) on the subject of higher criticism.  I was wanting to get Kevin Wilson’s take on it since he has done extensive work in this area and he graciously obliged (writing from Lithuania).  Thanks for the insightful response! […]

]]>